- May 2012 Issue
- A Meh Market: Surveys Reveal Slight Growth in Legal Revenues, Greater Growth in Expenses
Law by the Numb#rs
A Meh Market: Surveys Reveal Slight Growth in Legal Revenues, Greater Growth in Expenses
Posted May 1, 2012 12:59 AM CST
By Dan DiPietro and Gretta Rusanow
Authors DiPietro and Rusanow ended the Citi Private Bank Law Watch quarterly flash survey on 2011 legal industry financial statistics with an upbeat “all said, not a bad year.” But that rosy assessment gathers some shade in a historical view of the mainly large law firms that participated.
In the 2011 flash survey, DiPietro and Rusanow report revenue for the legal services industry grew 4.1 percent for the year, certainly a step up from 2010’s 1.3 percent. Yet both were well below the 10.9 percent compound annual growth rate for revenue rung up during the period from 2001 to 2007. Further, the 2011 survey showed expenses grew at a higher percentage than revenues—4.4 percent—while the 2010 survey showed an expense decrease of 2.2 percent.
The 2010 flash survey reported results from 179 participants, including 134 Am Law 200 firms (46 of the top 50, 38 from firms 51-100 and 50 Am Law Second Hundred firms) and 45 additional firms. The 2011 report surveyed 178 participants, including 128 Am Law 200 firms (45 of the top 50, 36 from Am Law 51- 100 firms and 47 Second Hundred firms) and 50 more law firms.
Those statistics also colored the 2012 Client Advisory (PDF) issued by the Hildebrandt Institute and Citi Private Bank in late winter. Noting the “economic malaise” that’s hit legal services since mid-2008, the advisory declares “the best way to describe the overall economic prospects of the industry—at least in the near term—is ‘uncertain.’ ” It says demand for legal services, equal to total billable hours for the reporting firms, increased 0.2 percent in 2010 and 1 percent in 2011.
Results for the 2012 Client Advisory came from 116 law firms reporting to the Thomson Reuters Peer Monitor and included 45 Am Law 100 firms, 41 from the Second Hundred and 30 other firms. Also participating in the advisory report were James Jones, senior fellow at the Center for the Study of the Legal Profession at Georgetown University Law Center, and Hildebrandt Consulting founder Brad Hildebrandt.
The advisory cited slowed demand in the second half of 2011, especially in corporate and transactional practices. Expense growth (despite cuts in headcount since 2009) came from both increased compensation for fee earners and overhead costs, including purchases that had been deferred during previous cost cutting.
And whether one sees the reported revenue results as improvement over 2010 or still disappointing from past boom years, the 2011 Law Watch flash survey anticipates that better times may not be around the next corner. Those results, the survey says, are “likely to be the new definition of a good year for the legal industry at least for the foreseeable future.”
Survey authors are Dan DiPietro, chairman of Citi Private Bank's law firm group, and Gretta Rusanow, director and senior client adviser at Citi Private Bank's law firm group.