Posted Aug 01, 2010 10:00 am CDT
Who is your favorite fictional lawyer? Vote here.
Hollywood loves lawyers. TV loves lawyers. And literature? Well, from Shakespeare to Dickens to Grisham, there is no shortage of fictional lawyers for us to admire, disdain or, above all, simply remember.
We wondered how the fictional lawyers of film, television and literature would stack up against each other. Of course, in some cases they are the same. The Perry Mason of Erle Stanley Gardner’s popular novels is lost in Raymond Burr’s television portrayal. John Mortimer’s Horace Rumpole will forever have the face of actor Leo McKern. But whatever the medium, it is the character we come to love or loathe—whether as a lawyer, a detective, a hero or a human being.
In our survey of this literature of lawyers, however, we feel obliged to recognize a great divide—ante-Atticus and post-Atticus.
From Dick the Butcher’s famous pronouncement to Jack Cade in Shakespeare’s Henry VI, Part 2—“First thing we do, let’s kill all the lawyers.”—through Dickens’ Mr. Tulkinghorn and Galsworthy’s Soames Forsyte, literature (with a few exceptions) treated lawyers poorly.
That all changed with Harper Lee’s unflappable, unforgettable Atticus Finch. With Atticus, the lawyer—once the criminal mouthpiece, the country club charlatan, the ambulance-chasing buffoon—was now an instrument of truth, an advocate of justice, the epitome of reason.
Finch was comfortable in his own skin and reasonably respectful of the frailties in others. To lawyers, he was the lawyer they wanted to be. To nonlawyers, he fostered the desire to become one.
So for this, and other reasons (See “Farewell, Atticus”), we’ve withdrawn Atticus Finch from this particular literary comparison, allowing our panel of experts to rank their favorite fictional lawyers without the heavy lifting required by a demigod.
So here are our panel’s choices for the 25 greatest fictional lawyers (none of whom are named you-know-who).
Cover photographs—(top row): 20th Century Fox / The Kobal Collection, Warner Bros/The Kobal Collection, NBC / The Kobal Collection, Castle Rock/Section Eight / The Kobal Collection, ABC-TV/The Kobal Collection / Baer, Carin, Columbia / The Kobal Collection. (second row): United Artists/The Kobal Collection, 20th Century Fox / The Kobal Collection, Warner Bros / The Kobal Collection, FX Network / The Kobal Collection, United Artists / The Kobal Collection, Columbia / The Kobal Collection, 20th Century Fox / The Kobal Collection, United Artists / The Kobal Collection. (third row): United Artists / The Kobal Collection, Columbia / The Kobal Collection, Speaking Parts LTD / Alliance Comms / The Kobal Collection / Eisen, J, 20th Century Fox / The Kobal Collection, Evening Standard / Getty Images, 20th Century Fox / The Kobal Collection, CBS-TV / Plautus Productions / The Kobal Collection. (bottom row): Warner Bros/The Kobal Collection, CBS-TV / The Kobal Collection, Universal TV / Wolf Film / The Kobal Collection / Hart, Will, 20th Century Fox / The Kobal Collection.