Appeals Judge Perks in Pennsylvania: Luxury Cars, Law Firm-Financed Trips
Pennsylvania Chief Justice Ronald Castille drives a 2010 Cadillac, but he’s not paying the lease costs. He has attended dinners, golf outings and a social meeting at a luxury hotel, but he’s not picking up the tab.
The state pays for the Cadillac lease, a perk provided to state appeals judges, the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review reports. Twenty-five judges lease taxpayer-financed cars, including Justice Max Baer of Mt. Lebanon. Baer drives a 2010 GMC Acadia he leases at government cost from his brother’s Washington dealership, the story says. Thirteen judges don’t participate in the program.
Meanwhile some of Castille’s dinners and outings are paid for by lawyers and business people, including some with cases before the court, the Philadelphia Inquirer reported earlier this month. Last December, he attended a meeting of the Pennsylvania Society, a state booster club, at New York City’s Waldorf Astoria. The law firm Saul Ewing paid the $1,900 tab for the hotel room and dinners, just as it had done the previous two years.
A New York Times editorial criticizes the state ethics rules that allow Castille and other appeals judges to accept gifts as long as they disclose them. The state supreme court has ruled that it alone has the authority to set the ethics rules; almost no other state has rules that would allow the gifts.
Similarly, the state auditor general can’t audit the judiciary budget. “Appellate judges spend what they want, with little accountability,” the Tribune-Review says, quoting the opinion of Duquesne University law professor Bruce Ledewitz.
The Inquirer found that Castille’s votes show “no pattern of favoritism,” but the Times isn’t satisfied. “Even a judge whose conduct seems above reproach can’t avoid doubt about his impartiality when he accepts gifts from lawyers and others with cases before him,” the editorial says.
Castille said in a May interview that he accepts rounds of golf as gifts from friends at golf courses he could never afford, but did not give the Inquirer an interview for its November story. Saul Ewing lawyer Timothy Carson told the Inquirer the firm financed Castille’s New York trip because the justice should have a chance to interact with other state leaders.
Castille didn’t comment to the Tribune-Review on his car lease. Baer told the newspaper that judges need upscale reliable cars to travel safely in bad weather. He said his brother provides the car lease “at cost.”
Hat tip to How Appealing.
