Law Schools

Are law student loans in danger of default? Not according to past history, law prof says


Image from Shutterstock.

Contrary to a recent report, law students are a good credit risk for the federal government, according to a law professor who has valued a law degree at $1 million in a lifetime.

Writing at Brian Leiter’s Law School Reports, Seton Hall University law professor Michael Simkovic says loans to law students are among the most profitable in the federal government’s student loan portfolio. That’s because the students pay higher interest rates while maintaining a low default rate.

Leiter’s blog post is a response to a New York Times editorial that accuses for-profit law schools of “vacuuming up hordes of young people, charging them outrageously high tuition and, after many of the students fail to become lawyers, sticking taxpayers with the tab for their loan defaults.” The Times editorial warned that an increasing number of nonprofit law schools were engaging in the same behavior.

According to Simkovic, the two-year default rate in 2010 was 12.1 percent for those with a bachelor’s degree and below, and 7.1 percent for those with a master’s, doctoral or professional degree. Looking at loan default rates for law schools that report their rates as independent institutions, Simkovic has estimated default rates for all law students at 1.7 percent. His number is adjusted for the fact that the reporting law schools are disproportionately low-ranked institutions.

The three-year default rate in 2010 was 20.1 percent for those with a bachelor’s degree and below, and 11.6 percent for a master’s, doctoral or professional degree. Simkovic estimates the three-year default rate for law students that year at 2.8 percent.

Florida Coastal, a for-profit law school highlighted in the Times editorial, had low three-year default rates of 1.6 percent in 2010, 5.2 percent in 2011, and 1.1 percent in 2012, Simkovic says.

“It would be a mistake,” Simkovic says, “to let the small tail of defaults wag the much larger dog of public benefits.”

We welcome your comments, but please adhere to our comment policy and the ABA Code of Conduct.

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.