Legal Ethics

Beleaguered Ga. Judge Won't Respond to Prosecutors' Filing in Nichols Case

A respected Georgia judge under fire for requiring the state to pay defense costs it says it can’t afford in a complex capital murder trial won’t contest a state supreme court filing seeking to force him off the case.

Instead, Superior Court Judge Hilton M. Fuller Jr. has sent a one-page letter to the supreme court, saying that he doesn’t believe it’s appropriate for him to become involved in a war of words with the prosecution in a pending trial, reports the Atlanta Journal-Constitution.

The case that has created the furor concerns a March 11, 2005 courthouse shooting in which four people, including a Fulton County judge, were murdered. Defendant Brian Nichols faces a 54-count indictment, and, despite free and reduced-fee legal services provided by some of his attorneys, has already reportedly racked up a legal bill of well over $1 million on the state’s account.

As discussed in earlier posts, the prosecutors contend that the judge has exceeded his authority in defense-funding matters by requiring Georgia to pay defense fees in excess of a funding cap. (Fuller has halted the trial and initiated contempt proceedings because Nichols’ lawyers aren’t being paid.)

Meanwhile, some legislators—who say the current defense cost tab is closer to $2 million—are pursuing possible impeachment of the judge.

We welcome your comments, but please adhere to our comment policy and the ABA Code of Conduct.

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.