Criminal Justice

Chicago Upholds Far Fewer Excessive Force Complaints than Other Cities, Witness Testifies

Security camera footage.

Most cities uphold on average 6 percent of excessive-force complaints against police officers, but in Chicago, only 2.7 percent were upheld, a witness testified Tuesday, in a federal civil case involving an off-duty officer convicted of beating a female bartender.

The numbers reflect a time period between 1999 and 2004, a Mount Sinai Hospital epidemiologist testified for plaintiff Karolina Obrycka. Her action, according to the Chicago Tribune, alleges that the city’s police department disciplines few officers, and there’s a large “code of silence” that protects bad cops from punishment. The defense questioned how the witness’ data was collected.

In 2007, Obrycka’s lawyers released a video of Anthony Abbate beating her at the bar where she worked. The release came shortly after Abbate, then a Chicago Police officer, was charged with a misdemeanor. Following the video’s release his charges were upgraded to felonies, and he was convicted of aggravated battery. He was later fired from the Chicago Police Department.

We welcome your comments, but please adhere to our comment policy and the ABA Code of Conduct.

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.