Law Firms

Did Greenberg hide tea-time document incineration accident? Claim won't be heard; case is tossed

An appeals court has tossed a lawsuit accusing Greenberg Traurig of failing to disclose that a document central to its client’s defense was “burned under highly suspicious circumstances”—a claimed tea-time incineration accident.

Greenberg won dismissal of the suit by plaintiff James Melcher on statute of limitations grounds, the New York Law Journal reports. Melcher had sued under a New York law providing for treble damages when a lawyer participates in “deceit or collusion” with the intent to deceive a court or a litigant. The New York Appellate Division, First Department, ruled for the law firm in a 3-2 opinion last week.

Melcher, a former member of the hedge fund Apollo Medical Fund Management, had claimed Greenberg Traurig deceived a Manhattan court in his prior suit for a share of hedge fund profits.

The alleged deception: Greenberg had represented it was holding in escrow a document reducing Melcher’s membership rights in the fund. But firm didn’t disclose that the document had been partly incinerated by a hedge fund principal who claimed he accidentally set fire to the paper while making tea, Melcher claims.

Melcher was awarded $500,000 in his prior suit against the hedge fund, the New York Law Journal says.

We welcome your comments, but please adhere to our comment policy and the ABA Code of Conduct.

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.