- En Banc 7th Circuit Says Parking Tickets May Violate Privacy Statute; Posner Predicts Scofflaw Suits
En Banc 7th Circuit Says Parking Tickets May Violate Privacy Statute; Posner Predicts Scofflaw Suits
Posted Aug 8, 2012 1:10 PM CST
By Martha Neil
A federal statute enacted after a California actress was murdered by a stalker who got her address from state motor vehicle records also applies to parking tickets, a federal appeals court has ruled.
In an en banc decision (PDF) on Monday, the Chicago-based 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals reversed prior rulings and said the Driver's Privacy Protection Act was potentially violated by a Chicago suburb's claimed policy of listing detailed personal information on parking tickets placed on vehicles in public view, reports Courthouse News.
The complaint, which is assumed for the purpose of a motion to dismiss to be true, alleged that the ticket issued to plaintiff Jason M. Senne included his name, address, driver's license number, date of birth, height and weight, the 7th Circuit noted.
"Mr. Senne’s appeal requires that we examine the scope of the DPPA’s protection of personal information contained in motor vehicle records and the reach of its statutory exceptions. We now conclude that the parking ticket at issue here did constitute a disclosure regulated by the DPPA, and we further agree with Mr. Senne that, at this stage of the litigation, the facts as alleged are sufficient to state a claim that the disclosure on his parking ticket exceededthat permitted by the statute," the majority wrote. "Accordingly, we reverse the judgment of the district court and remand for further proceedings consistent with this opinion."
Potentially, the en banc majority decision could create as much as $80 million in liability for the village of Palatine, Ill., a three-judge dissent said.
Another dissent authored by Judge Richard Posner said the majority decision, in response to a potential parking-ticket stalking situation that, as far as anyone knows, has never arisen, opens the floodgates for a potential tidal wave of frivolous class action litigation on behalf of parking scofflaws.
"From now until the statute is amended (unless today's decision is reversed by the Supreme Court first), only a sucker would park legally in the village of Palatine," Posner wrote.
An Electronic Privacy Information Center page provides detailed information about the DPPA and how it was enacted in response to the murder of actress Rebecca Schaeffer in 1989.
ABAJournal.com: "Kansas City Police Say 7M License Plate Shots Showing Date, Time and Location Are a Public Record"
Los Angeles Times (2003): "Allstate Pays $1-Million Fine for Improper Use of DMV Records"
Los Angeles Times (1991): "Into the Line of Fire : Rebecca Schaeffer's Death Led Her Parents to Fight for Gun Control"