Legal Ethics

Fed'l. Judge and Mississippi AG are in Name-Calling Contest

Although recommending no civil or criminal penalties, a federal judge didn’t hold back when he criticized Mississippi’s attorney general, Jim Hood, in a written opinion issued yesterday. In no uncertain terms, he reportedly says Hood went too far when he allegedly helped Richard Scruggs, a prominent Mississippi plaintiffs attorney who has since been disgraced, evade a court order concerning confidential insurance company documents related to Hurricane Katrina.

U.S. District Judge Acker calls Hood a “so-called law enforcement officer” in the opinion, which concerns Scruggs’ handover of the documents that two clients had obtained from a former employer to Hood, rather than to the former employer’s lawyer. But that may not be the worst of it: “This court now finds by a preponderance of evidence that, in context, General Hood was not a bona fide ‘law enforcement official,’ but rather was a co-conspirator with, and an aider and abetter of Scruggs,” the judge says at one point in the opinion, reports the Clarion-Ledger in an article reprinted by the Hattiesburg American.

However, not to be outdone, Hood issued a press release today calling for Acker, who sits in Birmingham, Ala., to revise “uncalled-for derogatory conclusions” in the opinion, reports the Associated Press.

He also had a few other points to make, the Clarion-Ledger writes:

“The rules of judicial performance do not allow a court to engage in unnecessary attacks on officers of the court, particularly when they are not even parties to the litigation,” Hood states. “This judge interfered with a grand jury investigation and we believe that either he, an appellate court, or the Alabama Commission on Judicial Performance will remedy this situation.”

He plans to file a motion requesting that Acker revise his Thursday opinion, according to the newspaper.

Almost lost in the war of words is the $65,000 civil contempt penalty Acker did impose in his order against Scruggs and his two clients. For more details, read this Sun Herald article.

Additional and earlier coverage:

Wall Street Journal Law Blog: “Spat Between Mississippi AG, Alabama Federal Judge Heats Up” “Scruggs Says He’ll Accept Suspension Over Disbarment” “Long Live the King of Torts?” “US Attorney to Judge: No Scruggs Case” “Judge: Scruggs in Criminal Contempt”

Untitled Document

We welcome your comments, but please adhere to our comment policy and the ABA Code of Conduct.

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.