Trials & Litigation

Rape defendant wins mistrial after prosecutor's claim that he tried to run her down is disproven

William Payne was jailed without bail for seven days after a prosecutor claimed he nearly ran her down while driving outside the Buffalo, N.Y., courthouse in which a jury was being selected for his rape trial.

But the 48-year-old defendant has never had a driver’s license or owned a car, and Niagara Frontier Transportation Authority security camera footage shows he was taking a train and a bus home at the time of the alleged incident last week, his lawyer, Joseph A. Agro, tells WIVB.

The Buffalo News also has a story about the claimed near-miss, which resulted in Payne’s bail of $25,000 being revoked and a mistrial in the Erie County rape case.

Judge Kenneth F. Case reinstated Payne’s bail after seeing NFTA security photos during a Monday hearing, calling the prosecutor’s accusation against Payne a matter of mistaken identity.

A mistrial was declared, the newspaper says, because prospective jurors overheard courthouse talk about a traffic incident involving the prosecutor.

Payne’s trial is now scheduled for August. He is charged with third-degree rape and third-degree incest.

2 registered sex offenders were wearing GPS devices during serial slayings, police say

Ethics complaint alleges lawyer billed NCAA for her whistleblower client's bankruptcy depositions

We welcome your comments, but please adhere to our comment policy. Flag comment for moderator.

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.