Criminal Justice

Judge Reinstates Molestation Charges Against Doc Accused of Exaggerating Alzheimer's

A California judge has reinstated child molestation charges against an 80-year-old psychiatrist accused of exaggerating Alzheimer’s disease to avoid trial.

Judge John Grandsaert of San Mateo County concluded that William Ayres is competent for trial after a four-day hearing, report the San Mateo County Times and the San Mateo Daily Journal.

Grandsaert cited a report by a psychologist at Napa State Hospital, where Ayres was sent after the first trial ended in a hung jury and Ayres was found incompetent for retrial. The report said Ayres displayed mental and reasoning ability, including:

• Ayres helped a nurse spell “Alzheimer’s.”

• After a court hearing, he asked if he had the same room and went there on his own.

Defense lawyers argued the single report was contradicted by a dozen mental health professionals, including two doctors at Napa. They said dementia patients have good days and bad days, so it is possible Ayres was sometimes lucid.

We welcome your comments, but please adhere to our comment policy and the ABA Code of Conduct.

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.