White-Collar Crime

Judge who reduced verdict from $5M to $1M, expecting campaign gift, gets 10 years in bribe case


Michael Maggio

Michael Maggio. Image from Arkansas Judiciary.

A former Arkansas judge was sentenced Thursday to a maximum 10-year prison term for admittedly reducing a jury verdict in the expectation of a contribution to his planned campaign for a state appeals court seat.

Michael Maggio, now 54, lost his seat on the Faulkner County Circuit Court bench after the reason for his reduction of a $5.2 million nursing home verdict to $1 million came to light. However, at least for now, he has not been ordered by U.S. District Judge Brian Miller to pay the $4.2 million in restitution that federal prosecutors sought, according to the Arkansas Blog of the Arkansas Times and the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette.

Miller said he wanted the sentence in the Little Rock case to reflect the harm Maggio had done.

“What’s worse: a drug dealer on the corner or a dirty judge?” the judge said Thursday. “A dirty judge is far more harmful to society than a dope dealer.”

Maggio opted not to speak in court. His lawyer, James Hensley, told reporters that Maggio plans to appeal.

Related coverage:

ABAJournal.com: “Ex-judge gives up law license after taking plea in federal bribery case over jury verdict”


We welcome your comments, but please adhere to our comment policy and the ABA Code of Conduct.

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.