Legal Ethics

Lawyer Fined $500 for Filing Suit in Spat Over Damaged Designer Umbrella

A lawyer has been fined $500 for filing a frivolous lawsuit on behalf of a New York restaurateur who claimed a model damaged the limited edition designer umbrella he loaned to her.

Attorney William Beslow sued supermodel Le Call on behalf of Nello Balan, the owner of a well-known Italian restaurant on the Upper East Side. Balan initially sought $1 million for his emotional distress and other damages, contending that that he loaned Le Call a limited edition Jean-Paul Gaultier leather umbrella on a rainy day, only to have it returned months later in two pieces, according to the New York Times and Associated Press.

Although he later amended his claim to seek a mere $30,000 in damages, state Supreme Court Justice Joan Madden found even that amount to be excessive in a case concerning an umbrella alleged to be worth $5,000 when brand-new, the newspaper reports. The Manhattan judge ordered Beslow to pay $500 to the Lawyers’ Fund for Client Protection and routed the case to small claims court.

Earlier coverage:

New York Post (2007): “Model Rains on Nello Umbrella”

Untitled Document

We welcome your comments, but please adhere to our comment policy and the ABA Code of Conduct.

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.