Attorney Fees

McGuireWoods Denied Fee in $49M BAR/BRI Settlement; Conflict Cited

A federal judge has ruled that McGuireWoods won’t get any attorney fees in a $49 million antitrust settlement with BAR/BRI parent company West Publishing Corp.

U.S. District Judge Manuel Real ruled earlier this month that the law firm is not entitled to $12 million in fees because of a conflict of interest that violated ethics rules, according to the Legal Pad blog and the Wall Street Journal Law Blog.

The problem: McGuireWoods offered incentive payments to some but not all of the class representatives. Six plaintiffs who objected to the settlement argued the sliding-scale payments gave the plaintiffs no reason to push for a higher settlement after their incentives were capped out. As a result, the interests of those plaintiffs clashed with others in the class represented by McGuireWoods.

Law Blog calls the ruling “stunning” and “a strange result.”

Real ruled after the San Francisco-based 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the settlement but asked the judge to re-evaluate attorney fees.

The class action suit had claimed West Publishing Corp. conspired with Kaplan Inc. to monopolize their respective markets for test preparation courses.

We welcome your comments, but please adhere to our comment policy and the ABA Code of Conduct.

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.