Trials & Litigation
N-Word Question Spurs Tiff in Case of Lawyer Demoted for ‘Ghetto’ Remark
Posted Sep 24, 2009 10:17 AM CST
By Debra Cassens Weiss
Is it more offensive for a white person to use the N-word than for a black person to use it?
That question was put to Detroit Deputy Mayor Saul Green during a deposition in a suit filed by the city’s former top lawyer, who was demoted for telling court staffers that one court was perceived as a “ghetto court,” the Detroit News reports. The lawyer, Kathleen Leavey, claims in a reverse discrimination suit that her ghetto remark would have been overlooked if she were black.
During his deposition, Green was asked whether the word “ghetto” is racist. He said the answer would depend on the context. When he was asked the N-word question, a lawyer for Detroit instructed him not to answer it.
Now Leavey’s lawyer, James Fett, is asking a federal judge to sanction the city for instructing Green not to answer, according to the story. The question "goes to the heart of the matter," Fett says. In the alternative, Fett wants Green to be allowed to answer the question and to be deposed again at the city’s expense.

Comments
B. McLeod
Sep 24, 2009 11:22 AM CST
I think there is a “form of the question” issue. “More offensive” to whom? If the questioner means the Deputy Mayor (who only has foundation to answer for himself), how is it relevant evidence or designed to lead to relevant evidence? Also, my recollection from prior reports is that the plaintiff resigned and bumped back to a lower position. If she thought her comments were perfectly appropriate and defensible, why the resignation? It certainly detracts from the credibility of her later rationalization that she said nothing wrong.
Flag this comment
jbolaw
Sep 25, 2009 1:43 PM CST
The American public is becoming so hyper-sensitive to the use of any word that somehow, somewhere, at some time miight offend someone else that freedom of speech has become a mockery. The so-called “N” word, because of its charged history, is probably not a word to use in “polite” society, but ghetto is not a racist term. The original ghettos were in Eastern European countries and primarily used to isolate Jews, not blacks.
Flag this comment
Add a Comment
We welcome your comments, but please adhere to our comment policy.
Commenting has expired on this post.