Trials & Litigation

Suit by NY Lawyer Claims Health Club's Cold Breakfasts Broke Full-Menu Promise

A Manhattan lawyer has sued a luxury health club, saying it stopped providing a full hot breakfast as promised.

The suit by Richard Katz seeks $730,000 against the Setai Club & Spa Wall Street. The Associated Press, the New York Daily News and the New York Post have stories.

Katz claimed he renewed his $5,000 annual membership based on a promise that he would continue to get a full free breakfast. Previously, Katz tells the Post, the club provided breakfast at a nearby eatery with “a full restaurant menu like you get in a hotel—omelets, pancakes, waffles, yogurts, meats, juices.”

When the restaurant closed for a month, the spa substituted a cold buffet on a roof deck. The Daily News says Katz was kicked out of the health club for complaining, while the Post say he was allowed to quit and given a pro rata refund in fees.

The suit seeks $230,000 over the breakfasts and $500,000 for an allegedly libelous comment, AP says.

We welcome your comments, but please adhere to our comment policy and the ABA Code of Conduct.

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.