Criminal Justice

Vermont DUI Convictions May Be in Jeopardy Over Alleged Breath-Test Errors

Hundreds of Vermont DUI convictions are being challenged by defense lawyers, who claim there was a mistake in the breath analysis machine’s software setup.

Whistler-blowers’ complaints about unethical lab work also figure in, the Associated Press reports.

Human error resulted in one machine at the Royalton State Police barracks operating for almost a year without a self-check function, which was supposed to ensure the device worked properly. Two state Department of Health chemists failed to activate the self-check function, the AP reports, before the machine went into use.

“People can go to jail and lose their driver’s licenses based on this science,’’ George Ostler, a Norwich defense lawyer, told the AP. “When they don’t maintain the machines like this, it’s disturbing.’’

We welcome your comments, but please adhere to our comment policy and the ABA Code of Conduct.

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.