Tort Law
Foreign Courts Look Askance at Punitive Damages
Posted Mar 26, 2008, 10:17 am CDT
By Debra Cassens Weiss
The awarding of punitive damages has long been accepted in the United States, but it’s rare in other countries.
Most foreign courts view punitive damages as a windfall for plaintiffs, the New York Times reports. These courts say punishments should be meted out by the criminal justice system or by government regulators rather than lay jurors given to ad hoc opinions.
The practice “is regarded almost universally outside the U.S. with a high degree of disfavor,” lawyer Gary Born, who works in London, told the Times.
As a result, foreign courts are reluctant to enforce punitive judgments obtained against foreign corporations obtained in U.S. courts. In one case last year, the Italian Supreme Court refused to enforce a $1 million judgment against the maker of a motorcycle helmet, the story says. The money was awarded to the mother of Kurt Parrott, who died in a motorcycle crash when the helmet’s buckle failed and his unprotected head hit the pavement.
Nonetheless, a few foreign courts are changing their attitudes. Supreme courts in Canada and Spain have enforced punitive awards, and the Supreme Court of South Australia said it would consider enforcing such awards when cases involve “brazen and fraudulent conduct.”
That is no comfort to Judy Glebosky, the mother of the motorcycle rider. “A million-dollar award is really nothing,” she told the Times. “It’s really not enough to punish any large company in this day and age, and it certainly does not bring back Kurt.”
Related Stories
- Spain Claims US ‘Pirates’ Stole Sunken Treasure from Underseas Galleon
3 hours, 13 minutes ago - Grand Jury Convened re Borrowed Courthouse Key
5 hours, 11 minutes ago - N.Y. Lawyer Gets 25 Years to Life in Murder of Client’s Husband
5 hours, 42 minutes ago - After 6 Years, R. Kelly Trial Begins
6 hours, 30 minutes ago
Commenting has expired on this post.
Comments
Posted by anonymous - 1 month, 1 week, 6 days, 22 hours, 52 minutes ago
If foreign companies want to do business on US soil, they have to abide by US laws. If US business want to do business on foreign soil, they have to abide by that countries’ laws. I can’t stand it when some other country says, f-you to our laws but has no quams about making billions in our country. That is when the US gov’t ought to step in and seize their US assets to satisfy the US judgment!