Lawyer won't have to pay $1M to law student after making a hyperbolic challenge in TV interview

  • Print

A Florida lawyer who promised in a television interview to pay $1 million to anyone who could disprove his client’s alibi won’t have to pay the Texas lawyer who tried to collect, a federal judge has ruled.

In a decision issued last week, U.S. District Judge Charlene Edwards Honeywell ruled against San Antonio lawyer San Dustin Kolodziej, who was a law student when he first tried to collect. The Volokh Conspiracy and Courthouse News Service covered the opinion (PDF).

The problem, Honeywell said, was that Kolodziej was acting on edited comments by Florida lawyer James Cheney Mason that didn’t reflect his true offer. As a result, there was no mutual assent, Honewell said.

Kolodziej was a student at South Texas College of Law when he saw the televised NBC Dateline interview in which Mason promised to pay $1 million to anyone who could prove the prosecution’s theory of a case against his client. Prosecutors had alleged that the defendant, shown on a security camera at a hotel several hours before and after a quadruple murder in Florida, used an alias to fly to Florida, committed the murders, flew back to Atlanta under a different alias, and returned to the hotel 28 minutes after the flight landed.

Kolodziej took the flight and drove to the hotel in less than 28 minutes, recording his performance of the challenge. He sent Mason a letter seeking to collect the money.

In the televised interview, the reporter summarized the prosecution theory and Mason’s comment followed. “I challenge anybody to show me—I’ll pay them a million dollars if they can do it,” he said. “Twenty-eight minutes, can’t happen. Didn’t happen.”

But, according to Honeywell, the unedited transcript showed Mason’s comment was directed at prosecutors. “Not possible. Not possible,” Mason said. “I challenge anybody to show me, and guess what? Did they bring in any evidence to say that somebody made that route, did so? State’s burden of proof. If they can do it, I’ll challenge ‘em. I’ll pay them a million dollars if they can do it.” The reporter interjected, “If they can do it in the timeline,” and Mason responded, “Twenty-eight minutes.”

Mason’s client was convicted of the murders in 2006. The interview was recorded during the trial, but didn’t air until it was over, according to Courthouse News Service.

Prior coverage: “Recent Law Grad Files New $1M Suit Against Lawyer in Prove-Me-Wrong Dare”

Give us feedback, share a story tip or update, or report an error.