Criminal Justice

Raring for a Jury Trial, Defendant Appeals When Prosecutors Drop the Case

Ernest Pagels Jr. says he has a right to a trial by jury, even if prosecutors don’t want to pursue charges against him.

A Wisconsin appeals court disagreed and rejected Pagels’ pro se appeal on Thursday, according to the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel blog Proof & Hearsay.

Pagels had paid a $36 jury fee and was prepared to fight a disorderly conduct citation when prosecutors dropped the charge, the story says. Pagels objected to the dismissal and appealed when the judge ignored his plea to allow the trial to proceed.

Pagels also asked the appeals court to refund the jury fee and his costs to subpoena three witnesses. His request was denied in an unpublished opinion.

We welcome your comments, but please adhere to our comment policy and the ABA Code of Conduct.

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.