Evidence

Ariz. Sheriff's Office, County Battle Over Control of Archived E-Mails


Last month, an attorney for the Maricopa County, Ariz., Sheriff’s Office told a federal judge that the office hadn’t kept thousands of e-mails that could have been turned over to plaintiffs who had filed a civil suit against the office alleging racial profiling. The judge sanctioned the Sheriff’s Office.

But last week, county officials announced that those e-mails had actually been archived in response to an order by a county attorney in an unrelated lawsuit involving the county treasurer, the Arizona Republic reported.

County attorney Julie Pace told the Republic that not only were some of the e-mails relevant to the civil racial profiling suit, but others had been subpoenaed by a federal grand jury investigating allegations that the office is abusing power.

The Sheriff’s Office says the e-mails are its property. The Republic said that Sheriff’s Commander Bob Rampy approached county technology managers and demanded the e-mails be turned over, but the county refused, saying the e-mails are county property.

“They never once told anybody that for the last 2½ years, they’ve been backing up every single e-mail,” Sheriff’s Office attorney Eric Dowell said. “If some attorney is looking at my attorney-client [privileged] e-mails, there are going to be some ethical problems.”

Meanwhile, Arizona Chief Justice Rebecca White Berch has appointed a special investigator to probe Maricopa County Attorney Andrew Thomas as a result of allegations that Thomas acted unethically in prosecutions of county officials. Thomas is already being investigated by the FBI for potential abuses of power.

Previous:
Juror’s Comment About Defense Lawyers Justified Mistrial, Appeals Court Says

Next:
Attorney Firings Get Just Four Pages in Rove Memoir


We welcome your comments, but please adhere to our comment policy. Flag comment for moderator.

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.