Question of the Week
What Inappropriate Halloween Costumes Have You Seen at the Office?
Posted Oct 28, 2009 1:02 PM CST
By Molly McDonough
We received a press release last week with a warning to employers to be careful about costume parties at which workers dress up in ways that could wind up as litigation nightmares.
“Employees should have a work environment free of obvious or not-so-obvious harassment," advises Steve Miller, who practices with Fisher & Phillips in Chicago.
One costume raising labor and employment red flags this year is the "illegal alien" getup. Retailers Target and Walgreens have already been pulling the controversial costume—complete with green card—off websites and store shelves, the Chicago Tribune and others have reported.
All this made us wonder about your Halloween office-party horror stories.
So tell us ...
What inappropriate Halloween costumes have you seen employees wear to work?
Answer in the comments below.
Read answers to last week's question: In Law School, How Many Hours Per Day Did You Study?
Featured answer:
Posted by PeteMoss: "The minimum amount needed to pass. No notes either. And it showed. I was third in my class—from the bottom. When I found out that I was ranked 46 out of 49, I was crushed. I could have slacked off even more and come in dead last. Why? Even the three people behind me graduated and sat for the bar. I spent my study time looking for—and landing—a job in my field of choice. A much better use of my time."

Comments
O'Neaux
Oct 29, 2009 9:17 AM CST
A woman came dressed as a “kitty”. Wearing only a sleeveless black leotard and tights with “cute” little ears on a headband and an “adorable” tail. Oh, did I fail to mention this was in a court house?
AndytheLawyer
Oct 29, 2009 9:34 AM CST
I once practiced at a firm where an inept fool of a partner masqueraraded as a competent lawyer. He did not limit the costume to Halloween.
Will
Oct 30, 2009 3:40 AM CST
I live and work in Holland. Here there is an incredible offensive costume. It is more frequently seen at Christmas but you do see it at Halloween sometimes. It is the “zwarte piet”. This is one of Santa Claus’ helpers, which in the Dutch tradition are black slaves! Adult white men paint themselves in blackface with big red lips and afros, and parade around as these comical simpletons, looking like Al Jolson! Almost no one objects to it and people who are actually black don’t object because then the other Dutch accuse them of trying to take away their “culture”! Please tell your friends all over the world, look it up wikipedia, and get the word out about this horrible racist practice here!
John
Oct 30, 2009 5:06 AM CST
It’s only offensive if you view it from the perspective of an arrogant, politically correct American. It’s refreshing to see that the Dutch have not allowed their cultural heritage to be suffocated like we have. What’s next are “little people” going to start complaining about Santa’s elves? We are so busy worrying about everybody’s feelings that we lose a lot of productivity and forget how to have fun.
Fred
Oct 30, 2009 6:08 AM CST
Andy the Lawyer FTW.
LHS
Oct 30, 2009 7:05 AM CST
Pulling the “illegal alien” costumes is so dumb. That really disgusts me. They’re actually funny. It’s one thing to make fun of things that people are born with and can’t change, like race or mental ability, but this doesn’t fall into that category. Too PC for their own good, give me a break.
Brian D
Oct 30, 2009 7:20 AM CST
I wholeheartly agree with LHS. I think people should dress up as people who get overly sensitive about these issues. Now that’s a scarey costume (a overly sensitive liberal).
MaryM
Oct 30, 2009 7:26 AM CST
I LOVE the Illegal Alien costume! It is hilarious!
Coco
Oct 30, 2009 7:28 AM CST
Nobody should dress up at work; sorry.
Joe
Oct 30, 2009 7:33 AM CST
The bigger issue here is not “inappropriate” or “appropriate” costumes, but rather why do adults need to dress up for Halloween in the first place? I stopped dressing up for Halloween when I was like 13 because Halloween is for children! In this country’s long past heyday when people had dignity and class, normal adults didn’t dress up for Halloween…Just like everything, Halloween has had to become an industry onto itself that, in order to grow, must expand beyond children to adults as well.
Lori
Oct 30, 2009 7:37 AM CST
We used to encourage everyone in the office to dress up for Halloween. I’m not sure why. This practice stopped after the managing partner’s legal assistant dressed as a french maid, complete with fishnets, short skirt, and stilettos. She carried a little duster around as well. While this was disturbing attire for the office, her outfit was surpassed by one of the male associates. The guy is 6’4”, at least, and he dressed as a Hooter girl with fake breasts, a blond wig, and the tighest orange shorts I’ve ever seen on a man. After this, we were no longer allowed to dress up for Halloween.
Joe
Oct 30, 2009 7:42 AM CST
Remember folks, this thread is for answering a question: “What Inappropriate Halloween Costumes Have You Seen at the Office?”
So far, I have seen no constumes at all.
Let’s try to answer the question.
LHS
Oct 30, 2009 7:53 AM CST
Good grief Joe, because it’s fun. Try to have a sense of humor. What a stick in the mud.
HBA
Oct 30, 2009 7:58 AM CST
Hmmm—green card—doesn’t that make the person a LEGAL alien?!?!?
Joe
Oct 30, 2009 8:07 AM CST
LHS: Our “fun” is a continued source of enjoyment to our competitors in China who are laughing all the way to the bank and to dethroning the U.S. as the new superpower. Our “fun” and our nation’s collective ignorance when it comes to global issues contributed to us getting into the mess we’re in now.
G. R. Grekko
Oct 30, 2009 8:09 AM CST
I have to agree with Joe. Costumes are not work approp. That being said to answer the question, I have seen a girl wearing above the knee boots with a very very mini skirt. Which normallly would be amazing, but she was 40+. I almost lost my breakfast and I was glad that she was on the otherside of the office.
Lily
Oct 30, 2009 8:16 AM CST
Just google “Julie Myers Halloween” and you’ll see the most inappropriate work costume ever. A deportation officer dressed up as a detainee.
You know it’s bad when CNN covers your Halloween party.
Diamond Jim
Oct 30, 2009 8:19 AM CST
We have an annual firm Halloween party and any female associate or secretary who is not in costume must participate in our wet t-shirt contest.
LHS
Oct 30, 2009 8:40 AM CST
Joe, I never extolled the virtues of store-bought costumes. I’ve never bought a costime in my life, only an occasional accessory like a witch hat, the last of which I’ve had for at least 10 years, stores flat, and is easily stored in perfect “working” condition. I would be the last person to condone wasteful, synthetic costumes, shipped from overseas, to be worn once, with packaging, no less. If you can’t even imagine that it’s possible, and yes, “fun,” to come up with any sort of creative costume from items you have at home - bandanas, hats, pipecleaners, cardboard - you have additional problems other than being a sour bump on a log. I would never support mass consumption just because I do think dressing up can be fun; quite the contrary. Go get some sunshine and sit under a tree. It would do you wonders.
Joe Swador
Oct 30, 2009 9:09 AM CST
All of you don’t realize, it isnt so much what it was as what it can be or the perception of how things are determined. If you all can’t see your actions are or, or were, or even could be, the thing that triggers an exaggeration of what it was in the first place. Your ignorance is shocking.
R
Oct 30, 2009 9:17 AM CST
1. Gosh, Joe, I feel absolutely terrible about contributing to America’s dethronement as a superpower because I bought a Halloween costume… LOL
2. The fact that the “Illegal Alien” costume that’s so wildly popular nowadays comes with a GREEN CARD proves that in the eyes of many, you’re automatically “illegal” if you look like one (i.e., if you look Hispanic).
3. #1, 11 and (maybe) 16: could you please submit photos of those costumes to ABAJournal and if so could ABAJournal please run them (with faces pixellated out). I think it would be very instructive.
4. As for my office, one man once showed up dressed as a fat old woman. To make matters worse, he hadn’t taken along any regular clothes to change into… By the end of a long workday he seemed thoroughly depressed.
Joe
Oct 30, 2009 9:37 AM CST
R: Kid all you want…the America you grew up in won’t be the same American you die in. Everyone attacking my comments do not go to the substance and are merely making light of them.
Maybe this isn’t the right forum for this debate, but it goes without saying that while one purchase alone does not have the effects I spoke of, millions of similar purchases do.
tim
Oct 30, 2009 9:40 AM CST
huh - if I wear an illegal immigrant custom and I get called out for it - i will be the one suing for harrassment.
what’s wrong with dressing up as an illegal immigrant?
i’d find a custom of obama more offense than of an illegal immigrant
LintRoller
Oct 30, 2009 9:41 AM CST
Art imitates life, so I’m not a big fan of focusing on offensive costumes. For those who are championing a less racist world, good for you. I’m totally with you on this, but please work on issues like disparities in education, healthcare, imprisonment, and opportunity, before railing on someone’s Halloween costume.
That said, since art can influence life, if you’ve already been working on those bigger issues, then feel free to comment on costumes.
Even though I agree with the sentiments involved, I disagree with those who think they can tackle a society-wide problem by heaping scorn on an individual.
jeff
Oct 30, 2009 10:14 AM CST
Joe - stop contradicting yourself.
First you make off topic comments. (see post 10)
Then you remind others what the topic is and that they shoud stick to it (see post 12).
Finally, in post 22, you take your own advice and state “maybe this isn’t the right forum for this debate.”
WHAT IS YOUR PROBLEM???
Joe
Oct 30, 2009 10:19 AM CST
Jeff: I posted Nos. 10 and 22; I did not post No. 12…hmm, maybe it’s possible that there could be more than one “Joe” in the World?
NativeNewYorker
Oct 30, 2009 10:41 AM CST
John/#4: I sincerely hope you are being sarcastic in your comments that being offended of racism is somehow being arrogant. If not, your comment only proves the point that some white people, wherever they live, don’t think it’s in bad taste, offensive or wrong to make fun of others—who aren’t white. I suppose you also thought it was funny when Princess Diana’s son dressed up as a Nazi.
NativeNewYorker
Oct 30, 2009 10:48 AM CST
WARNING: The “Julie Meyers Halloween” search in Google leads you you into a highly disgusting pornographic site.
trace
Oct 30, 2009 11:09 AM CST
Comment removed by moderator.
Bob
Oct 30, 2009 11:12 AM CST
#29 that was funny
Shannon
Oct 30, 2009 11:23 AM CST
I firmly believe lawyers should dress up in costumes everyday. Actually, that is what we do - dress up like penguins and think you are being “normal.” In terms of functional clothing, suits fail: they don’t provide warmth, durability, or freedom of movement. So why not wear something just as functionally useless, like a pumpkin costume?
T
Oct 30, 2009 11:52 AM CST
People still wear suits to work?
MNJD
Oct 30, 2009 11:54 AM CST
Joe#10… I bet you are a real hoot to party with… you sound like the life of the party
kasey
Oct 30, 2009 12:04 PM CST
One year some of the staff dressed up as a few of our more colorful attorneys. No one took anything too far - so as to spare feelings, etc—but the costumes and the immitations tht went with them were priceless. Everyone, including the “victims” had a very good laugh.
trace
Oct 30, 2009 12:38 PM CST
Joe - Just to cheer you up, the Mayan calendar says the world will end in December 2012 - just saying!
So party like its 1984!
Bob
Oct 30, 2009 12:42 PM CST
Lady Godiva takes the crown every year! It both the most appropriate and least appropriate costume at the same time - especially when bringing coffee to the conference room!
LHS
Oct 30, 2009 12:58 PM CST
Ha, Joe (of #10, 22, and 26) ignored my comment #19…ball of fire he must be anyway :)
Esq.
Oct 30, 2009 1:39 PM CST
I went to a swanky law firm Christmas party where a hostess wore a super-tight, super-revealling red and black lace bodice that showed far, far too much of her enormous breasts, and a Santa hat.
MacTheKnife
Oct 30, 2009 3:38 PM CST
@ 21 R - “2. The fact that the “Illegal Alien” costume that’s so wildly popular nowadays comes with a GREEN CARD proves that in the eyes of many, you’re automatically “illegal” if you look like one (i.e., if you look Hispanic).”
It proves nothing of the sort. I suppose everyone is entitle to an opinion, but uninformed and ignorant ones like yours regarding this comment about the illegal alien costume are without value or merit. If you had bothered to educate yourself as to what the illegal alien costume is, you would know it is a space alien in an orange jumpersuit with an oversized “greencard” the size of a magazine.
Elizabeth
Oct 30, 2009 3:42 PM CST
Glad to see the objectification of women is alive and well. Not to mention that “professionals” aren’t afraid to admit it on an ABA forum.
Adamius
Oct 30, 2009 3:47 PM CST
John (@ #4), you are everything that is wrong and backwards with the world. Remember that slavery was once a part of America’s “culture”, as was making fun of japanese and jewish people in children’s cartoons, as was slaughtering Native Americans either with superior weaponry or by underhandedly giving them blankets infected with disease. Some “culture” shows a people to be very UNCULTURED, and I for one am very happy to see those old ways die, dry up, and disappear. Secondly, you are obviously white. That costume couldn’t be offensive to ANYONE but an American? What about a black person? If you would be a little reluctant to wear that costume in front of a black friend of yours (and I’m sure you have MANY) [sarcasm], then you should realize it could be offensive to ANY black person. It also makes white people feel ashamed for the shameful behavior of their ancestors. There’s really nothing good about that costume, and anyone that feels it should be celebrated, I have no use for.
inventor of piano key necktie
Oct 30, 2009 4:30 PM CST
#18,
oh, so that’s what that was. I guess I was confused earlier. I thought their Halloween costumes were “Spring Break Co-Eds”
Honestly
Oct 31, 2009 11:44 PM CST
Great to see so many mindless racists in the comment section. If you’re actual lawyers, I pity the law schools that have you as alumni—and of course none of you have the gall to actually write your real names because you know exactly where it would put you. But there are many of us who know how to check IPs, and your days are numbered :-)
Really?
Nov 1, 2009 9:25 PM CST
#43 - Great you can track my IP address to the coffee shop, McD’s, airport, hotel, pub, or any of a billion other public wifi internet connections in the world… <shaking in boots> ;)
Caroline
Nov 1, 2009 10:01 PM CST
This comments thread is among the most upsetting and disgraceful I have seen on this site. I am ashamed that some of you are my colleagues - particularly the ones who condone sexist and racist costumes and activities.
I think that this one:
Posted by Diamond Jim - 2 days, 14 hours, 33 minutes ago
We have an annual firm Halloween party and any female associate or secretary who is not in costume must participate in our wet t-shirt contest.
is the most inappropriate costume/behavior I have heard of in the workplace.
Halloween is all fine and good, but there is a time and a place for everything and work is not the place for Halloween costumes, especially as legal professionals. There clearly aren’t enough of us who know where to draw the line between fun and inappropriate. By the way, I’m 27 and hold this view, not some cranky old partner.
Design Law
Nov 2, 2009 10:00 AM CST
A couple of our hot secretaries used to come dressed as either a mermaid or bunny, with very nice, tight costumes! Those were the days!!!
associate
Nov 3, 2009 11:22 AM CST
I think that this comment thread distinctly shows one thing: We need a mandatory first year class in sarcasm and humor. It’s clear that many here have no idea what either are (I’m looking at you Caroline at 45).
JF
Nov 3, 2009 3:44 PM CST
And the bulk of the high-horse, moralizing attorneys being scandalized and offended at a mere costume probably explains why the rest of the population doesn’t like attorneys…
khazeh
Nov 3, 2009 4:58 PM CST
associate @47, not all jokes are funny, and put-downs are not always funny to those you are putting down. You might wish to reconsider whether others share your sense of humor; you’re not going to get the opportunity to scold a partner or a big-ticket client about how PC they are and why they should be laughing at the same jokes you do.
On costumes, I’m thinking of a senior associate who showed up for Halloween in a hideous lime-green “pimp” costume - which would have been a lot less inappropriate if this particular attorney hadn’t cheated on his wife with several paralegals, and then gotten fired for having pornography on his work computer.
PeteMoss
Nov 4, 2009 3:47 PM CST
When my previous firm went to business casual, I often dressed more casually than business-ly. When I showed up in a suit around Halloween, one of the older partners yelled, “Look! (Pete) is dressed up like an attorney!”. If you cannot laugh at yourself…
Add a Comment
We welcome your comments, but please adhere to our comment policy.
Commenting has expired on this post.