College sports has been beset by change and litigation in recent years with the rapid rise of name, image and likeness payments, unlimited athlete transfers and more. The Protect College Sports Act of 2026, which the Senate passed by a 77-22 vote on Sept. 28, aims to curtail the chaos.
But would the comprehensive bill, if it becomes law, actually ease compliance concerns for those representing university athletic departments?
The bill would limit college athletes to one transfer between schools without having to sit out a year, subject to limited exceptions such as a head coaching change.
In addition, it would allow institutions to spend roughly $49 million annually in revenue-sharing payments to college athletes, including $22.5 million to retain their players. That represents a substantial increase from the current $21 million allotted for revenue sharing.
The bill also gives the NCAA, its athletic conferences and member institutions conditional antitrust immunity and caps agent NIL fees at 5%. However, the House of Representatives is out of session until after the midterm elections, making the bill’s path uncertain.
“It’s a good starting point,” says Matt Mitten, a Marquette University Law School sports law professor who supports the bill. “It would largely put an end to these 160-170-plus [athlete] eligibility suits that we’ve seen.”
He adds that the bill would set up a system through the federal courts.
“So you’re not getting home cooking and looking for the most favorable state courts, which is what we have now,” Mitten says.
But Robert Boland, a Seton Hall Law School sports law professor and partner with the Ohio-based Shumaker, Loop & Kendrick firm, actively opposes the bill and views it as a negative step. He served for five years as athletics integrity officer at Penn State.
“What has the NCAA done to earn antitrust immunity?” Boland asks. “By abrogating antitrust law, Congress is taking a really remarkable step. They have not extended antitrust protection to private actors like this since before World War II.”
He adds that if the bill passes, which he does not expect will happen, it will neither create ease nor end lawsuits.
James Nussbaum formerly was an in-house counsel at Indiana University, where he oversaw NCAA compliance for the athletic department. Now a partner with Church Church Hittle + Antrim, he says that putting a cap on compensation or revenue-sharing agreements with collective bargaining has issues.
“I’ve been consistently telling schools, ‘Hey, let’s pump the brakes on this’ for a lot of reasons,” Nussbaum says. He prefers giving student athletes a seat at the table but says most schools feel differently.
Interestingly, the Protect College Sports Act does not include a provision for whether revenue-sharing payments to athletes are subject to Title IX, which bars sex-based discrimination in federally funded colleges and schools.
“There’s still a vacuum in how Title IX applies to revenue share payments in NIL,” Nussbaum says. “There’s good guesses, but there hasn’t been any enforcement mechanism either from the federal government, the Department of Justice or the Department of Education.”
He adds that athletic departments he talks to think Title IX poses a really big risk.
“Those lawsuits are continuing to be filed, particularly any time an institution cuts or demotes a sport, it’s almost automatic that a lawsuit is coming,” Nussbaum says.
Ty Thomas, partner with Fox Rothschild, represents several NCAA Power Four universities. He says the economics of college sports make it apparent where the revenue is generated. “That does not mean there’s not an obligation to support sports in both genders.”
Thomas notes the bill includes language that tries to ensure colleges and universities are not cutting women’s sports to reduce costs. For instance, it allows institutions to set aside $5 million per year exclusively for women’s sports and nonrevenue sports.
But Boland fears that’s not enough, and it may give more colleges the idea to ignore Title IX.
"The protections inside the bill are fairly modest, and I think hollow,” he says.
Whether or not the bill becomes law, attorneys advising universities face a challenging legal environment on other fronts. Two key issues involve whether college athletes are ultimately deemed to be employees, and what happens if they unionize. The experts agree such a result could have a host of ramifications.
“Getting anybody the status of per se employment status brings in the whole wave of employment issues, which may or may not be for the betterment of student-athletes,” Thomas says.
Mitten agrees. He notes that the IRS has always taken the approach that athletic scholarships are not subject to income tax, which is a very significant benefit.
“I wonder if considering them employees, would the IRS revisit the issue of the athletic scholarship, and look at it and say that ought to be taxable?” Mitten asks. “If that’s the case, college athletes could be worse off.”
He also points to a sex discrimination case that arose involving the U.S. national men’s and women’s soccer teams as a cautionary example that led to a large class action settlement. The same could happen, Mitten says, in college sports.
“Let’s say at a school you’ve got the men’s and women’s basketball teams that have unionized. What if they negotiate different deals with the schools? And then one of the others says there’s sex discrimination here?” Mitten asks. “You can see just how complicated this is going to get.”
He also notes that more than half of NCAA Division I universities are public, and whether their athletes could unionize is a matter of state law.
Boland picked up on that point.
“If you’re in a state like Oregon, New York or Pennsylvania, could you organize your athletes as public employees, which will be exclusively outside the National Labor Relations Board’s jurisdiction, and you’ll be subject to state union efforts? And will those union efforts create a much more hostile labor environment?” he asks.
Regardless of whether the Protect College Sports Act is passed, Thomas and Mitten say that the job of representing a university athletic department calls for increasingly broader skills.
“We’re at a point now if you’re advising in college sports, you almost have to be able to have general counsel-type capabilities,” Thomas says. “You have to be able to switch your hat and look at different things depending on what your institution wants to do.”
According to Mitten, it’s difficult for a conference or NCAA counsel to say with any confidence that a rule will not be challenged in litigation by someone.
“The Wild West has really expanded to include our legal system,” he adds. “Who would have thought 20 years ago that college athletes could be employees, or they’d be getting revenue-share money from the schools? Things can change very quickly.”