Bar Exam

Florida can continue to charge veteran lawyers more to take bar exam, appeals court rules

The Atlanta-based 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled Friday that the Florida Board of Bar Examiners can charge more for experienced lawyers to take the bar exam. (Image from Shutterstock)

The Florida Board of Bar Examiners can continue to charge veteran lawyers more to take the bar exam than recent law school graduates, a federal appeals court has ruled.

The Atlanta-based 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled Friday that the board was immune from a lawsuit brought by practitioners from New Jersey and Michigan seeking admission to the Florida Bar, Bloomberg Law reports.

“The experienced-applicant rule draws no line based on where an applicant is from, so it doesn’t facially discriminate. And the undisputed evidence showed that the practical effect of the rule was to burden in-state and out-of-state applicants the same, and that the board proposed—and the Florida Supreme Court adopted—the rule for a valid purpose,” Judge Robert J. Luck said in his ruling.

According to Bloomberg Law, Florida’s bar admission rules increase fees the longer applicants wait to take the bar after graduation. The lowest fee is $700 to sit for the exam, and it rises to as much as $3,000 based on years of experience, the court said. Lawyers Steven Hernandez and David Drwencke alleged that system discriminates against out-of-state attorneys looking to sit for the bar, violating a doctrine under the U.S. Constitution called the “dormant commerce clause.”

Luck ruled, however, that since the board of bar examiners is an arm of the state, it’s immune from federal suit over this rule. In addition, the attorneys’ claims against the board’s executive director fail because the rule doesn’t disproportionately impact nonresidents. About 45% of the “experienced” applicants subject to higher fees are already state residents, Luck said.