Your Voice

The Pink Suit Problem: Preparation can help head off problems that are ultimately peripheral

Michelle Quist Michelle Quist.

By the time I arrived in Denver on a Sunday evening in September, I was already behind. I had two arguments scheduled before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit that week, one on Monday morning and another on Wednesday. My flight had been delayed, and instead of spending the weekend immersed in briefs, transcripts and outlines, I had spent it across the country attending my oldest daughter’s white coat ceremony.

Objectively, it was a wonderful reason to be distracted. Subjectively, as every appellate lawyer knows, any deviation from the ideal preparation schedule can feel catastrophic.

By the time I finally made it to my hotel room, it was late. I unpacked, spread papers across the desk, reviewed my notes, revised a few talking points, and rehearsed answers to questions I imagined the panel might ask. I stayed up far later than I should have, trying to make up for lost time before eventually surrendering to exhaustion.

The next morning, I got myself together, looked over my notes one last time, and headed to the courthouse.

The 10th Circuit has always held a special place in my heart. Years ago, after an eight-year hiatus from legal practice while raising children, I had the privilege of clerking for Judge Monroe G. McKay. He was my mentor, my teacher and ultimately a friend. Some of my fondest professional memories come from my time at the court, and I still think about the lessons he taught me nearly every time I stand up to argue a case.

As I walked toward the courthouse that morning, I found myself thinking about him. I remembered walking those same halls as a law clerk and felt a familiar sense of gratitude for having had that experience. As I climbed the imposing stairs toward the entrance, thinking of Judge McKay and all he had meant to me, my heart suddenly dropped into my stomach.

I had made a terrible mistake. Not a jurisdictional mistake. Not a record-citation mistake. Not even a waiver mistake. A wardrobe mistake.

You see, I had recently gone through some weight changes and needed to replace much of my professional wardrobe. None of my old suits fit anymore, including the reliable black skirt suit that had accompanied me through countless court appearances. In its place, I had purchased a few beautiful new suits.

The problem was that I had purchased them for fashion, not for court.

As I stood on the courthouse steps, I suddenly realized exactly what I was wearing: a muted pink pantsuit. Not partially pink. Entirely pink. Head to toe. Beautiful? Absolutely. Expensive? Unfortunately, yes. Appropriate attire for oral argument before one of the most conservative courts in the country? That seemed much less certain.

I immediately began looking for a solution. Then I remembered that I had brought a second suit. Relief washed over me for approximately three seconds. My other suit was forest green. Not navy. Not charcoal. Not black. Forest green.

At that point, the full magnitude of the problem became apparent. Somehow, in the frenzy of replacing an entire wardrobe, I had focused on cut, style and color and never stopped to consider that appellate advocacy has its own fashion norms. There are reasons lawyers standing before federal appellate courts tend to favor dark, conservative colors, and none of those reasons had occurred to me while admiring seasonal collections.

Like any rational lawyer confronting an issue she cannot immediately solve, I turned to Google.

I searched whether it was acceptable to wear colorful suits while arguing before a federal appellate court. The internet was not reassuring. The consensus seemed to be that dark, conservative colors remained the safest choice, and that lawyers should avoid drawing attention to themselves through their attire. This information did not make me feel better.

I began imagining judges discussing my clothing. Law clerks discussing my clothing. Court staff discussing my clothing. I wondered what Judge McKay would have thought.

At first, I knew exactly what he would have done. He would have raised an eyebrow. Anyone who knew Judge McKay can probably picture the expression.

But as I stood there panicking, another memory surfaced. One of his favorite sayings was, “But for the grace of God, go I.” It was an expression of humility and perspective, a reminder not to be too quick to judge the mistakes of others because we all make our own.

Eventually, reality asserted itself. The argument was going to happen. My suit was going to remain pink. There was no plausible way to fix the problem before the panel took the bench. So I walked into court.

And something unexpected happened. Once the argument started, the suit stopped mattering.

The judges asked questions about the law. I answered questions about the law. We discussed precedent, standards of review, statutory interpretation and the merits of the case. The argument unfolded exactly as oral arguments are supposed to unfold. Nobody asked about my suit. Nobody commented on my suit. Nobody appeared remotely interested in my suit.

To be fair, they may have noticed it. It would have been difficult not to. But if they did, they had the professionalism to focus on what everyone was there to discuss: the case.

Two days later, I returned for my second argument. In the green suit.

By then, I had given up trying to pretend I possessed an appropriate appellate wardrobe. Having survived the pink suit, I decided to embrace the consequences of my earlier shopping decisions.

To this day, I have no idea whether any judge, law clerk or member of the court staff remembers either suit. Perhaps they do. Perhaps they do not. Perhaps they spent the week wondering why an attorney had apparently confused the 10th Circuit with a fall fashion catalog. I prefer not to know.

Looking back, there are a few lessons in the experience.

The first is obvious: prepare. Not just the argument. Everything. Travel plans, logistics and apparently clothing choices. Five minutes of advance thought could have spared me a great deal of unnecessary anxiety.

The second lesson is that lawyers spend a remarkable amount of time worrying about things that are ultimately peripheral. We worry about whether we stumbled over a sentence, whether a judge seemed skeptical, whether opposing counsel sounded more polished, whether our voice shook, or whether we wore the wrong color suit. Some of those concerns merit attention. Many do not.

And that leads to the final lesson. At the end of the day, the only thing actually at issue during oral argument is the argument itself. The quality of the preparation, command of the record, understanding of the law, and ability to answer the next question from the bench matter infinitely more than whether a lawyer is wearing black, navy, charcoal, pink or forest green.

The older I get, the more I think Judge McKay would have appreciated that distinction. He might have raised an eyebrow. In fact, I am quite certain he would have raised an eyebrow. But after that, I suspect he would have reminded me to keep things in perspective.

After all, nobody ever won an appeal because they wore a black suit. And thankfully, nobody loses one because they wore a pink one.


Michelle Quist is a partner in Buchalter’s Salt Lake City office and a member of the litigation practice group, representing clients in civil, regulatory, appellate and business matters. Her experience includes commercial disputes, service with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit, and work as an editorial writer and a political commentator.


ABAJournal.com is accepting queries for original, thoughtful, nonpromotional articles and commentary by unpaid contributors to run in the Your Voice section. Details and submission guidelines are posted at “Your Submissions, Your Voice.”

This column reflects the opinions of the author and not necessarily the views of the ABA Journal—or the American Bar Association.