Federal judge grants new trial because of dozing lawyer
The owner of a Pennsylvania company deserves a new trial for alleged mortgage fraud because his lawyer dozed off several times during the proceedings, a federal judge has ruled.
U.S. District Judge Donetta Ambrose ruled (PDF) Monday that the dozing was substantial enough to violate James Nassida’s Sixth Amendment right to effective counsel, report the Legal Intelligencer (sub. req.), the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette and Courthouse News Service.
The lawyer, Pittsburgh solo Stanton Levenson, told the Legal Intelligencer that he dozed off only a couple times and it was because of an antihistamine he was taking.
Levenson had also blamed his sleepiness on the antihistamine when Ambrose questioned him during the trial about a prosecutor’s assertion that he appeared to be sleeping during testimony by a government witness. Nassida told the judge he wasn’t troubled by the incident and he was prepared to go forward with the trial.
As the trial progressed, however, Nassida said Levenson had fallen asleep at other times and he was concerned about his ability to get a fair trial. Levenson joined in Nassida’s mistrial request, and Ambrose said she would rule on the motion if the jury returned a guilty verdict.
Nassida was convicted in October 2016. Several jurors told Ambrose they had seen Levenson sleeping, though they differed on the duration and number of times. Some said the sleeping lasted only about 30 seconds at a time, while others said it lasted a few minutes. One juror said the sleeping happened four or five times, while others said it was a couple of times.
In a post-trial hearing, Nassida said he had observed his lawyer sleeping a couple times a day, for a total of about 20 times. Each time, Nassida said, he would nudge his lawyer to waken him.
Levenson testified in the hearing that he had slept during the trial but he didn’t know how long. During cross-examination, Levenson said he was asleep for 30 seconds at most and he often closes his eyes to concentrate.
Nassida, who ran Century III Home Equity, is accused of inflating his clients’ income and assets to obtain fraudulent mortgage loans from lenders. Ambrose has appointed a new lawyer to represent him.