Government admits mistake in answer to SCOTUSblog founder Tom Goldstein’s tax evasion appeal

Do letters and words matter? Yes—and certainly for jury instructions—according to lawyers representing convicted attorney Tom Goldstein, a SCOTUSblog co-founder and a high-stakes poker player who was found guilty of tax evasion and making false statements on loan applications.
In a Sept. 10 court filing, his lawyers argued that the government wrongly used jury instructions language from 18 U.S. Code Section 2(a) of the U.S. Department of Justice’s Criminal Resource Manual, which states that committing an offense against the United States or being somehow involved in the behavior is punishable.
In its answer filed Oct. 27, the government admits that it meant to to use language from Section 2(b) of the direction. It states that willfully causing or doing an offense against the United States is punishable.
“The government candidly admitted it had erroneously conflated the two subsections, a common mistake,” according to the answer.
It also argues that there was no jury instructions error. The jury was not allowed to convict on Section 2(a) because the court exercised its discretion and did not read it, according to the filing.
Additionally, the filing challenges Goldstein’s argument that the government made a Brady error regarding Walter Deyhle, the SCOTUSblog co-founder’s accountant. It also argues that the court correctly excluded text messages on the basis that they were hearsay with someone called “Kids,” an associate of a businessman who invested in Goldstein’s poker games.
Law360 has additional coverage.
Write a letter to the editor, share a story tip or update, or report an error.


