Artificial Intelligence & Robotics

5th Circuit blasts federal judge for AI errors in rulings

AP Mississippi Judge Henry Wingate_400px

U.S. District Judge Henry T. Wingate of the Southern District of Mississippi in August 2022. (Photo by Rogelio V. Solis/The Associated Press)

Suspecting artificial intelligence-generated errors, a federal appeals panel has overturned a preliminary injunction barring a Mississippi law that prohibits diversity, equity and inclusion in public schools and universities and ordered the case to be reassigned to a different judge on remand.

In an Oct. 22 opinion, Judge Jerry Smith of the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals at New Orleans criticized the district court proceedings, noting that the temporary restraining order by U.S. District Judge Henry T. Wingate of the Southern District of Mississippi enjoining enforcement of the law “contained several factual assertions nowhere to be found in the record, or indeed, in any proceeding of the case.”

Smith noted that this included mention of plaintiffs and defendants who were not in the complaint, “declarations” from people who did not exist or were never present, and false quotations that were supposedly taken from the text of the law. He also said when these errors were discovered, Wingate replaced the order without an explanation.

Wingate later acknowledged that a law clerk used AI to draft the order, and that it was docketed by mistake, according to a story by Courthouse News Service. However, the appeals panel said the judge’s corrected version of the order also contained hallucinated information.

“Given that the preliminary injunction order ‘generally incorporates by reference its discussion and analysis in its TRO,’ the hallucinated case discussed above is arguably part of the shoddy reasoning of the preliminary injunction, too,” Smith said in the opinion.