Ethics

Judge denies allegations he made inappropriate comments during disciplinary hearing

Appointed to the bench in 2012, Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Robert Draper lost his reelection bid in June to Los Angeles County Deputy District Attorney Tal Khan Valbuena. He will remain on the bench until January, unless the commission, which is expected to announce a decision in the coming weeks, removes him sooner. (Photo by Getty Images)

A Los Angeles judge defended himself Wednesday at a hearing before the California Commission on Judicial Performance, which is weighing allegations that he made inappropriate comments about women and Black people from the bench.

Bloomberg Law reported Wednesday that Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Robert Draper appeared uncomfortable, nervous and awkward during the hearing.

The complaint, filed in January, largely centers on Draper’s handling of a 2022 case, Odom v. Los Angeles Community College District, in which a professor claimed that the district failed to protect her from sexual harassment by a colleague. The case involved no race-related claims, but the complaint alleges that Draper engaged in unprofessional exchanges with attorneys using terms, such as “coal black” and “light brown” to describe Black people. It also alleges that he referred to adult women as “little girls” and commented on the appearance of a female witness.

According to Bloomberg Law, during the hearing, Draper claimed that an attorney who was “dismayed” by his comments in the case was lying. He also cited a statement from attorney Jamie Wright, who wrote that he “treated me with the utmost courtesy.”

Draper then described Wright as a “beautiful young woman,” prompting Mani Sheik, the commissioner for the California Commission on Judicial Performance, to ask whether the remark concerned her appearance or her soul.

“To me, a beautiful young woman is like a beautiful young man. I’m not sexually attracted to him,” Draper said during the hearing. “A beautiful young woman is somebody with a soul that I thought was a very honest person.”

According to Bloomberg Law, Draper appeared nervous during the hearing and at times veered into unrelated tangents. Appointed to the bench in 2012, Draper lost his reelection bid in June to Los Angeles County Deputy District Attorney Tal Khan Valbuena. He will remain on the bench until January, unless the commission, which is expected to announce a decision in the coming weeks, removes him sooner.