Plaintiff who filed fraudulent case, trashed desktop computer hit with sanctions

A plaintiff responsible for filing about 70 class action lawsuits for illegal robocalling received sanctions from a Missouri federal judge after obstructing, delaying and hindering potential discovery in a case. (Image from Shutterstock)
A plaintiff responsible for filing about 70 class action lawsuits for illegal robocalling received sanctions from a Missouri federal judge after obstructing, delaying and hindering potential discovery in a case.
Law.com has the story.
On behalf of client Fisher Investments Inc., Atlanta-based Watstein Terepka sought sanctions against plaintiff Daniel Human and his St. Louis-based lawyer Edwin Butler. The sanctions motion alleges that Human failed to produce discovery and, when pressed, trashed his desktop computer and produced a “decoy” laptop.
In a Sept. 30 sanctions order, U.S. District Judge Matthew Schelp of the Eastern District of Missouri awarded fees and expenses to Fisher Investments.
“Human initiated this case in complete bad faith,” he wrote. “In short, the genesis of this entire action was Human’s fraud.”
Human gave a fake name along with his phone number to request Fisher Investments’ solicitations only to then bring claims under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act, which offers statutory damages of $500 to $1,500 per call, Schelp wrote. Fisher Investments refused to settle.
As they continued litigation, Schelp wrote, “Human and Butler obstructed, delayed and hindered the progress of this litigation by many means and relentlessly avoided their discovery obligations. Their conduct culminated in Human destroying his desktop computer two days before a court-ordered inspection of the device.”
Write a letter to the editor, share a story tip or update, or report an error.


