Judiciary

Appeals Court Tosses $2.1M Verdict in Judicial Appointment Dispute

  •  
  •  
  •  
  • Print

A Missouri appeals court on Tuesday overturned a $2.1 million verdict that jurors had awarded a Northland lawyer who claimed she was unfairly bypassed for a judicial appointment.

Lawyer Melissa Howard won the award in 2008 after a trial in which she argued the Kansas City Council acted improperly when it declined to select from a pool of finalists for a 2006 judicial vacancy and opted instead to seek a minority candidate for the job, the Kansas City Star reports.

But the Western District Court of Appeals reversed the verdict and held in its 15-page opinion (PDF) that the trial judge should have directed a verdict in the city’s favor because the Missouri Human Rights Act doesn’t apply to the city’s process for appointing municipal judges.

The court also denied Howard’s motion for attorney fees.

Give us feedback, share a story tip or update, or report an error.