Pre-K program at center of Supreme Court battle over religious freedom and government aid

In 2020, Colorado voters passed a ballot measure establishing a universal prekindergarten program, which offers every 4-year-old in the state up to 15 hours of free preschool per week.
The measure has resulted in Colorado having one of the nation’s highest levels of pre-K enrollment, which the state says will lead to stronger literacy, better performance on standardized tests and higher graduation rates.
But the program is not without controversy, and the case of St. Mary’s Catholic Parish v. Roy heads to the U.S. Supreme Court next week. It is the latest in a series of high court cases over government aid to private religious schools as well as clashes between Colorado and those who seek—based on their religious beliefs—to avoid serving LGBTQ+ individuals.
“This will be a big, major free exercise case,” says Roman Martinez, a Latham & Watkins partner and former career lawyer in the U.S. solicitor general’s office who analyzed the case for Georgetown University Law Center’s annual Supreme Court preview last month.
Colorado’s pre-K program is open to public, private and religious providers alike, but all must sign an agreement to adhere to the state’s quality standards, which include a nondiscrimination requirement that covers, among other things, religious affiliation, sexual orientation and gender identity.
The Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Denver, which oversees 34 Catholic preschools, believes the equal-opportunity mandate interferes with Catholic teaching on sexual orientation and gender identity.
“The church has a particular understanding of marriage as being between a man and a woman, given the biological realities of the body,” Abriana Chilelli, the then-acting superintendent of schools for the Denver archdiocese, testified in 2024. Same-sex couples seeking to enroll a child in a Catholic preschool would be advised of church guidance that bars them, she said.
Tracy Seul, the preschool director at St. Mary’s Parish in Littleton, Colorado, part of the Denver Archdiocese, testified that as the process for the new state program rolled out, “we found that the agreement would conflict with our beliefs,” and the archdiocese told its preschools not to apply right away.
The Denver Archdiocese and other faith-based preschool providers sought a religious exemption from the nondiscrimination requirement, but the Colorado Department of Early Childhood said no.
“I cannot grant an accommodation to a nondiscrimination … statement that’s in statute,” Lisa Roy, the department’s executive director, testified in a 2023 deposition.
Roy said Catholic schools had signed similar nondiscrimination statements for other preschool programs, such as an older Denver preschool plan.
“I don’t understand why this is more problematic than any of the other many opportunities that they’ve had over decades,” Roy testified.
Mary Michael Cooke, who was the transition director for the new universal pre-K program, testified in court that voters who approved the ballot measure believed that “it was important that all families had equal access, equitable access to preschool programs of their choosing and would not be discriminated against based on any of the factors that are included in the legislation and now in statute.”
Latest clash over religious freedom, government aid
The state’s refusal to provide an exemption was challenged under the First Amendment’s free exercise of religion clause by St. Mary’s and one other church in the archdiocese, as well as one family in the parish that says it missed out on state aid because the church preschool could not participate in the state program.
“Parents who want to send their kids to Catholic [preschools] don’t get the $6,000 benefit that you get if you send your kids to almost any other school,” said Mark L. Rienzi, the president of the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, the legal organization behind the challenge.
The St. Mary’s case is a follow-up to three recent cases in which the Supreme Court expanded its view on government aid flowing to religious schools. The court’s 2017 ruling in Trinity Lutheran Church of Columbia v. Comer, its 2020 decision in Espinoza v. Montana Department of Revenue, and its 2022 ruling in Carson v. Makin all overturned state exclusions of religious schools from generally available aid programs such as playground grants, scholarship tax credits and tuition aid.
The most recent of those, Carson, said the state of Maine’s exclusion of religious schools from a program providing state aid for tuition covering students from towns without public high schools failed strict scrutiny under the free exercise clause.
“The upshot of those cases is that the court said you can’t exclude religious schools because of their religious exercise,” Rienzi said last month at a Supreme Court term preview at the Catholic University of America Columbus School of Law, where he also serves as a professor. “Our argument in St. Mary’s is that that’s precisely what’s going on, as the state is keeping them out because of their religious exercise.”
The lawsuit argues that Colorado’s equal-opportunity mandate violated the Carson decision by excluding them from the pre-K program based solely on the Catholic preschools’ religious character and exercise, namely by requiring all families to be supportive of Catholic teaching.
But two lower federal courts applied Employment Division v. Smith, the 1990 Supreme Court decision that says the free exercise clause cannot exempt individuals from neutral, generally applicable laws. The courts held that the pre-K program’s nondiscrimination requirements met that standard.
St. Mary’s argues that the Colorado’s nondiscrimination mandate is not generally applicable because the state grants exceptions in the form of allowing preschools to express a preference to serve low-income students or students with disabilities. There is also a “catchall” provision in the program that a state official testified would allow a preschool to limit enrollment to “gender-nonconforming children,” to “prioritize ‘children of color,’” or to “grant preference to an eligible child based on the child and/or family being part of … the LGBTQ community.”
Colorado is “affirmatively encouraging preschools to serve particular communities and allowing a wide range of secular preschools to flout the mandate without penalty,” St. Mary’s says in a brief. “The inevitable result of Colorado’s thumb on the scale is that more Colorado children will be funneled toward preschools that share Colorado’s perspective on matters of sex and marriage.”
State defends anti-discrimination requirement
Colorado Attorney General Philip Weiser, a Democrat who is running for governor (with Election Day the same day as argument in the case), argues in a brief that his state encourages religious school participation in the pre-K program as long as the schools agree to the nondiscrimination requirement.
The challengers’ suit “makes clear that they seek the legal right to receive [Universal Pre-K] funding while excluding families based on their sexual orientation, gender identity and religious affiliation,” the attorney general says.
The state says the challengers are seeking to extend Carson with “a sweeping new rule requiring strict scrutiny of any burden on religious conduct arising from neutral, generally applicable public-benefits conditions. … This court need not, and should not, redesign free exercise doctrine to decide this case, which involves impartial and uniform conditions on providers of publicly funded services.”
And the state’s nondiscrimination equal-opportunity requirements “ensure that all Colorado parents—Catholic, Jewish, Muslim, gay or straight—can trust that their 4-year-olds will not be turned away from publicly funded preschools because of religion, sexual orientation, gender identity or other protected characteristic,” Weiser says in the brief.
Martinez, speaking at the Georgetown Law Center’s preview, noted Colorado’s recent lack of success at the court with cases involving the intersection of religious-expression claims and LGBTQ+ rights. “Colorado … does not have a great track record in these cases,” said Martinez, who is not involved in the case.
Those cases include Masterpiece Cakeshop Ltd. v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission, the 2018 decision holding that the state commission had violated the free-exercise rights of a baker who refused to make a custom wedding cake for a same-sex couple. (That outcome was a bit of an off-ramp for the court, which did not decide larger issues presented by the case.)
Next came 303 Creative LLC v. Elenis, the 2023 case in which the justices said the First Amendment barred the state from forcing a web designer with religious objections to same-sex marriage from creating a wedding website for a same-sex couple.
And just last term, in Chiles v. Salazar, the court sided against Colorado’s law against conversion therapy for minors on sexual orientation and gender identity as applied to the talk therapy of a Christian counselor who challenged the law.
“It does seem to me that in these cases, generally, what’s driving the court is a commitment to a type of pluralism,” Martinez said. “The court, I think, is very concerned about religious groups sort of having equal access and being treated equally as a matter of practice, not just as a matter of formalism.”
In the new case, Martinez said, “the tea leaves are pretty good for the challengers.”
Write a letter to the editor, share a story tip or update, or report an error.

