Supreme Court nominations

Barrett says she doesn't see Roe v. Wade as 'super precedent'

  • Print


Democratic Sen. Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota questions U.S. Supreme Court nominee Judge Amy Coney Barrett during her confirmation hearing Oct. 13. Image from C-SPAN.

Judge Amy Coney Barrett, the U.S. Supreme Court nominee, has acknowledged that seven cases are “super precedent,” but Roe v. Wade isn’t one of them.

During Barrett’s confirmation hearing Tuesday, Democratic Sen. Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota noted that Barrett wrote a 2013 Texas Law Review article on the topic. Barrett listed seven cases that were generally regarded to be super precedent, including Marbury v. Madison and Brown v. Board of Education.

Klobuchar asked Barrett how she would define super precedent. Barrett said the term, as defined in the scholarly literature, means cases that are so well settled that no one calls for them to be overruled.

The Roe v. Wade opinion establishing a right to abortion “doesn’t fall in that category” because there are still calls for it to be overruled, Barrett said.

A precedent should not be overruled just because it doesn’t fall on the super precedent list, Barrett said. It just means that the decision isn’t among the cases that no one questions anymore.

Barrett’s 2013 article listed these cases as super precedent:

Marbury v. Madison, upholding judicial review.

Martin v. Hunter’s Lessee, upholding Supreme Court review of state court judgments involving federal law.

Helvering v. Davis, upholding the Social Security Act.

• The legal tender cases, upholding the constitutionality of paper money.

Mapp v. Ohio, holding that the Fourth Amendment applied to the states through the 14th Amendment.

Brown v. Board of Education, holding the 14th Amendment bans the states from maintaining racially segregated public schools.

• The civil rights cases, holding that the 14th Amendment applies to state action rather than individual acts of discrimination.

Give us feedback, share a story tip or update, or report an error.