Lawyer for defendant seen shackled outside courtroom should have sought mistrial, Oregon Supreme Court says

An attorney should have sought a mistrial after jurors saw a criminal defendant shackled outside the courtroom, the Oregon Supreme Court ruled last week. (Image from Shutterstock)
The Oregon Supreme Court has found that an attorney representing a man whom jurors saw shackled outside a courtroom during his criminal trial should have sought a mistrial.
In a 68-page decision last week, with one justice dissenting, the state supreme court found that Quandray J. Nelson, who was on trial for sex abuse offenses related to domestic violence, had provided enough evidence to establish that his attorney did not offer adequate counsel, the Oregon Capital Chronicle via the Bulletin reports.
The decision partially reverses rulings from the Oregon Court of Appeals and the Malheur County Circuit Court, which previously denied Nelson’s requests for post-conviction relief on the grounds that his defense attorneys failed to provide adequate counsel.
Many U.S. courts have held that restraining a defendant in front of a jury violates their Fifth Amendment and 14th Amendment rights by creating a presumption of guilt in the wake of a landmark 2005 U.S. Supreme Court case. There was no precedent in Oregon for such a case, however, in the surrounding area of a courtroom, according to the Oregon Capital Chronicle. Nelson was wearing handcuffs and ankle restraints while local authorities transported him from a cell to a hallway.
The decision does not name the attorney at the time of Nelson’s trial. Neither an attorney for Nelson nor a spokesperson for the Oregon Department of Justice immediately responded to a request for comment.
Write a letter to the editor, share a story tip or update, or report an error.


